Embarcadero Plaza and Vaillancourt Fountain Threatened with Demolition

Author

Docomomo US Staff

Tags

Endangered, Advocacy
Image details

A coalition of advocates led by the Docomomo US/Northern California chapter have come together to advocate for the preservation and reuse of the Embarcadero Plaza and Vaillancourt Fountain in San Francisco. 

 

Update: Fountain on agenda for October 6th

 

From the San Francisco Arts Commission: The Vaillancourt Fountain will not be agendized as an item for discussion at the September 30th Visual Arts Committee (VAC). We anticipate this item will instead be agendized and discussed at the October 6th Full Commission meeting. Please note, Committee and Commission meeting agenda items are subject to change. Meeting agenda items and supporting documents will be confirmed and posted 72 hours in advance of scheduled meetings at sf.gov/artscommission.

 

Written comments will continue to be accepted and may be submitted to Arts Commission staff via email (to ART-info@sfgov.org) until 5:00 p.m. before the date of the meeting. Please note, written public comments submitted in advance of the meeting will not be read aloud during the meeting.

 

Members of the public who wish to speak in-person on the topic of Vaillancourt Fountain during the September 30th Visual Arts Committee, may still do under Item #2: General Public Comment. Any person speaking in-person during a public comment period may supply a brief written summary of their comments which shall, if no more than 150 words, be included in the minutes.

 

 

Update: Speak up now before the Sept. 30th hearing. 

 

We need you to take your most important action yet: make a public comment to oppose the deaccession, removal, and demolition of Vaillancourt Fountain in from of The San Francisco Arts Commission. This may be your only chance to stop San Francisco from losing one of its most important modernist landmarks.


You can do one or both of these:

  • Make public comments in writing at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting (before Saturday, September 27 2:00pm). Either use this form or send an email address to art-info@sfgov.org, craig.corpora@sfgov.org, tara.peterson@sfgov.org. Make sure you specify that your message should be included as public comment.
  • If you are local, make public comments in person by coming to SF City Hall on September 30, 2025 at 2:00pm during the SF Arts Commission’s Visual Arts Committee meeting. You will have an opportunity to comment (up to 3 minutes).
     
    • Meeting details:  Tuesday, September 30, 2:00 PM, San Francisco City Hall, Room 416. (meeting details here) (Google Maps, Apple Maps)
    • Note: We anticipate this item will be on the agenda for a vote, but agendas are not finalized until 72 hours prior. Thus, final confirmation will be known on Friday, September 26.

Update: September 21, 2025

 

On Friday, September 19, 2025, Docomomo US/NOCA and a coalition of local, national, and international groups sent a letter to San Francisco Arts Commission, Recreation and Park Department, the Project Governance Team, and all associated city agencies and partners with a clear message: Embarcadero Plaza and the Vaillancourt Fountain must be retained and rehabilitated for present and future residents and visitors. Read here.

 

Background

The City of San Francisco is reimagining the future of Embarcadero Plaza, designed by renowned landscape architect Lawrence Halprin, as well as the iconic Vaillancourt Fountain, a Brutalist masterpiece created by artist and sculptor Armand Vaillancourt. 

 

In June 2025, Docomomo US/NOCA attended a key stakeholder meeting with staff of the San Francisco Recreation and Parks Department (SFRPD) and a representative from BXP to discuss the Embarcadero Plaza and Sue Bierman Park Renovation Project. The meeting discussed the project’s goals, timeline, and challenges, with a particular focus on the future of the Vaillancourt Fountain and Embarcadero Plaza. NOCA board members advocated for a transparent planning process, the study of multiple design options—including robust preservation alternatives—and the protection of these significant public spaces. The discussion included perspectives on maintenance, funding, accessibility, and the importance of community engagement as the city considers the next steps for this vital civic landmark.

 

BXP, one of the nation's largest commercial property managers and developers, has owned the Embarcadero Center since 1998, which is immediately adjacent to Embarcadero Plaza. The Plaza is a public space owned by the city. BXP initiated a redesign for the five-acre plaza and park in partnership with the San Francisco Recreation and Parks Department (SFRPD). This public-private partnership, formalized in 2024, is considered essential to revitalize the site, given the city’s financial constraints. The effort aims to reimagine the space while addressing maintenance, accessibility, and community needs, including the addition of a dog park and extra seating. Unfortunately, the early designs of the space have consistently shown the removal of Embarcadero Plaza and the Fountain.

 

Preservation advocates are calling for a comprehensive study of design options, emphasizing the need for transparent cost comparisons and careful consideration of the site’s Modernist heritage. The Vaillancourt Fountain, a monumental work of public art, has suffered from deferred maintenance, but, crucially, experts agree it is not beyond repair.

 

SFRPD has stated that maintaining the fountain costs over $100,000 annually and that repairing the pumps and addressing structural issues could cost $3 million or more, with complete restoration potentially reaching $12–17 million. 

 

Docomomo US/NOCA and the coalition of advocates are urging the city to look to successful models—such as the preservation of the recently landmarked Boston City Hall and its surrounding plaza—and to pursue creative, inclusive solutions. Modifications could include ADA-compliant access, design-sensitive modifications, and water-saving strategies for the fountain. Above all, the process must be transparent and collaborative, with adequate public participation, ensuring the preservation of the plaza’s unique character for future generations.

 

Get Involved

The fate of Embarcadero Plaza and the Vaillancourt Fountain hangs in the balance. Community participation is vital to ensure these landmarks remain vibrant symbols of San Francisco’s history and culture. Visit the Docomomo US/NOCA website for more information and how you can get involved. On the website you can submit public comment and download Save the Fountain graphics.

Save the Fountain Media Updates

 

Save the Vaillancourt Fountain — and S.F.’s modernist history. Op ed in the San Francisco Chronicle by Ted Barrow, September 5, 2025

 

Vaillancourt Fountain Artist is Lawyering Up. The Cultural Landscape Foundation, September 9, 2025.